Ask Rita: Can We Discriminate in Favor of People with Disabilities?

Is it lawful to give preference in hiring to applicants with disabilities?

Dear Rita:

Our agency serves clients with mental health needs, and we like to provide employment opportunities to individuals with mental illness.

Can we say in the job advertisement for peer counselor that the applicant should have a mental illness?

We are doing this not only to provide employment opportunities to individuals with mental illness, but also so our counselors will better understand the challenges facing their clients.

Is it lawful to give preference in hiring to applicants with disabilities?

Signed,
Confused

Dear Confused:

The short answer is yes, if you’re careful.

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) only protects individuals with disabilities. The ADA does not make it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against an individual because the individual does not have a disability (see 42 U.S.C. § 12112).

According to an October 3, 1995 Guidance Letter from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), an employer does not violate the ADA by requiring that applicants for a particular position have a disability.

Many states have similar laws prohibiting discrimination against individuals with disabilities, but like the ADA, these laws typically do not protect those without disabilities. Find out more about the legal requirements for employers under the ADA.

However, proceed carefully. While the ADA does not prohibit employers from affirmatively hiring certain disability groups, you cannot specifically exclude other protected groups or individuals with other disabilities.

For example, if you want to hire only people with a history of alcoholism, you can’t exclude alcoholics who also have mental illness. In other words, an employer can’t pick and choose which alcoholics to hire on the basis of the other disabilities they may have.

In that example, an employer would still have a duty not to discriminate against an alcoholic that also has a mental illness if the individual was otherwise qualified for the position. And the duty to reasonably accommodate other disabilities would still exist.

A problem that employers may encounter with preferential hiring of people with disabilities is that while they can advertise that they want to hire people with certain disabilities, they cannot ask applicants medical questions before making a job offer. Only after having made a job offer can the employer verify that the applicant has the disability.

So, for instance, you could advertise that you’re seeking individuals with mental illness for a counseling position, but during the interview you can’t ask the applicant if they have or have had a mental illness. However, it is permissible to show the applicant the job description or describe the job duties and ask what skills or related experience the applicant would bring to the position.

If the applicant voluntarily discloses his or her mental health history that’s fine, but don’t ask any direct questions like “What diagnosis do you have?” or “When did your mental illness have its onset?” All questions in the application and interview should be focused on the applicant’s skills and experience related to the job for which he or she has applied.

Of course, it always is a good idea to have standard applications and interview questions that are asked of all applicants so that you can have evidence of fair treatment of all during the hiring process.

Also, nonprofits that have federal government contracts or subcontracts of more than $10,000 for supplies or services must adopt an affirmative action program to employ qualified individuals with disabilities and to advance such individuals in employment under Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act.

The requirement to comply with this law is typically included in the nonprofit’s contract to perform services or provide supplies to the federal government. Read more information about compliance with the Rehabilitation Act.

It is really great to hear that organizations are assisting and empowering workers with a history of substance abuse or a developmental disability to overcome barriers to employment.

Nonprofits with the mission to assist people with those very challenges are the employers who best understand what is needed — and sometimes, more importantly, what is not needed — by these workers.

You might also like:

• Drive Your Nonprofit’s Mission by Investing in Your People
• Supporting Caregiver Employees in the Nonprofit Sector
• Increase Safety for Your Nonprofit’s Team
• Ask Rita in HR: Should Murphy’s Law Be a Consideration in Making HR Decisions?
• Moving Beyond Performance: Making DEI Actionable

You made it to the end! Please share this article!

Let’s help other nonprofit leaders succeed! Consider sharing this article with your friends and colleagues via email or social media.

About the Author

Blue Avocado

Website | More Posts

Blue Avocado is an online magazine fueled by a monthly newsletter designed to provide practical, tactical tips and tools to nonprofit leaders. A small but mighty team of committed social sector leaders produces the publication, enlisting content from a wide range of practitioners, funders, and experts.

• Blue Avocado

  https://blueavocado.org/author/blue-avocado/

  Key Qualities and Skills to Look for in Potential Board Members
• Blue Avocado

  https://blueavocado.org/author/blue-avocado/

  Nonprofit Photo Contest
• Blue Avocado

  https://blueavocado.org/author/blue-avocado/

  The Most Successful Nonprofit Fundraising Strategies
• Blue Avocado

  https://blueavocado.org/author/blue-avocado/

  Nonprofit Leaders: How Does Your Nonprofit Measure Success?