Community Development: Strategies That Serve

by Amira Diamond, Melinda Kramer on March 11, 2019

Categories: Community and Culture| Leadership and Management Topic Tags: Mergers & Collaboration

After working for decades in international development, we’ve learned a lot that applies to nonprofits of all kinds, especially those passionate about building resilient communities. Let’s begin by looking at how things can go sideways if you neglect the critical strategy of actually asking the community you serve what they want and need.

“This borehole was not built by me, nor for me. Now it’s just a reminder of what is broken.” These were the words shared by our colleague in Ghana, standing beside the only well in her village, which was installed by an international aid organization whose name no one in the village could recall and whose presence was long gone. Replacement parts were nowhere to be found and villagers were not informed about maintenance or repair. And women (the primary water collectors in most of the developing world) were not included in planning where the well was placed or how it was constructed. She explained that with a defunct well, the village was actually worse off—women and girls were forced to collect water at the nearby river contaminated with E. coli, or to walk to another village.

This scenario, or ones similar to it, have played out all across the world, anytime an organization attempts to impose a solution to a community without enlisting their input first, as passionately articulated in Ernesto Sirolli’s amazing TED Talk. It’s a tragedy when nonprofits—with all the best intentions—end up actually making things worse for the communities they serve. In an attempt to not repeat these kinds of mistakes, Women’s Earth Alliance (WEA) was founded by a group of 30 women leaders from around the world who wanted to write a new story.

In our work we identified three strategies to powerful, lasting results in community development projects: positioning local leaders as the designers of their own future, ensuring their agency is front and center, and shaping solutions in teams versus silos.

Community Leaders as Designers and Owners of their Future

Old-model development can sometimes perpetuate the paradigm that there are those who “have” and those who “have not.” And those who “have not” need aid and need decisions made for them. But the problem is those in need rarely see themselves as victims.

In our work, we flipped this on its head and designed a strategy underpinned by the theory that, when availed access to vital resources, community leaders have the foresight, vision, and know-how to best design and implement solutions that last. What is most needed is to strategically support people to unleash and proliferate their firsthand knowledge and grassroots solutions. It’s less about “serving beneficiaries” and more about connecting leadership to bridge solutions and build networks of transformation.

We’ve seen this model work again and again. Whether your organization is working in an inner city or a community abroad, how do you include the community members themselves in the design of solutions and how to implement them?

Stakeholders’ Agency Front and Center

We realized early on that conventional development strategies often neglect to engage key stakeholders. This is true across all areas that nonprofits impact, not just in international development: key perspectives are often discounted in implementing solutions in youth services, healthcare, education, poverty, hunger, and so many other areas. Yet, the people most vulnerable to any crisis are actually best positioned to address on-the-ground impacts and challenges. Sure, we typically think about “target beneficiaries,” but stakeholders’ contributions are consistently overlooked, underfunded, and under-prioritized. Don’t let this happen to you, no matter what your focus!

For WEA, this belief is our central driving premise—that when grassroots women’s leadership is centered, everyone thrives. In our case, we observed three consistent trends that you can easily imagine applying to your work, albeit likely with a different constituency at the core:

1. Grassroots women leaders design community solutions with more precision, long-term vision, and holistic inclusivity than any outside aid worker.
2. Grassroots women leaders often identify solutions that are otherwise invisible to aid professionals and to men, since they are often the ones bearing the brunt of the crises.
3. The relationships and trust between grassroots women leaders and their communities increases the likelihood that these solutions will be welcomed and endure.

How are you encouraging stakeholder leadership in your community initiatives? What have you noticed about the success of solutions that are conceived and implemented by local leaders, as opposed to solutions imposed upon them?

Teams Rather than Silos

We regularly recall the words of a Swahili song: “If we were all here, all here together…We could do wonders.”

For all of us engaged in making change, our work exists inside of an intricate and whole system of many parts and thinking about it that way helps to ensure long-term success. Every program your nonprofit undertakes should be co-designed by a team of local organizations and advisors—each bringing a diverse set of skills, networks, and resources. The result is a stronger, more dynamic, and more resilient offering.

Leaders in our programs learn from each other as much as they learn from “experts.” They uplift, refine, and launch community-led solutions that work. We’ve supported this silo-tipping by inviting program participants to join in teams of two in order to support each other once they return to their communities; consider doing the same or identifying other ways to build bridges. Rather than competing for funding, teams achieve exponentially greater impact by joining forces, thus enrolling a broader population, and integrating a diverse set of perspectives into each stage of their work.

How have you used teams and networks to connect people and create stronger program offerings? What best practices have you found in joining forces with others and integrating diverse points of view when designing solutions? Share below in the comments. We’d love to hear from you!

Always remember that your work should happen through, not to, the communities you serve. And when you employ the strategies of positioning local leaders as the designers of their own future, ensuring their agency is front and center, and shaping solutions in teams versus silos, your ability to do that increases exponentially, as do the results and impact of your work.

Melinda Kramer is a passionate advocate for social justice, the environment and women’s rights. An environmentalist by training, with a cultural anthropology background, Melinda has lived and worked around the world learning from grassroots leaders on the frontlines of environmental crises.

In 2005, she set out to bridge the resource gap for grassroots women tackling our world’s most critical environmental efforts, founding Women’s Earth Alliance. WEA’s global team has developed and iterated a unique training framework, equipping 5,000 women with technical, entrepreneurial, and leadership skills, and they in turn have reached over a million people with safe water, energy access, regenerative farming, land rights, and climate protection initiatives.

Amira Diamond is WEA’s Co-Director, focusing on expanding WEA’s programs, building the WEA team and creating a community of support for its work. Active within the NGO community for over 20 years, she has worked for community health, environmental and food justice, LGBTQ, and women’s rights, directing organizations like Julia Butterfly Hill’s Circle of Life and Democracy Matters. She graduated from Colgate University with a degree in Women’s Studies, studied Women and Development at the University of the West Indies in Jamaica, and attended Starr King School for the Ministry in Berkeley. She also holds certification as a Holistic Health Counselor.