What Most Boards Get Wrong About Executive Compensation (and What the IRS Actually Requires)
Setting an executive director’s salary should not come down to a national average or a quick Google search. Here’s a practical way for nonprofit boards to build a relevant peer group, use Form 990 compensation data, and document the decision.
A few years ago, I was sitting on the board of the Wanna Learn More Network, an LGBTQ+ advocacy nonprofit I’d helped launch.
We were hiring our first executive director, we needed to set a salary, and our budget was under $100K. We took the responsibility seriously. We knew the IRS expects boards to document how they arrived at “reasonable” compensation, and we wanted to do it right.
So, I went looking for data. Candid’s compensation report cost several hundred dollars, ERI’s nonprofit assessor required a subscription, and an outside compensation consultant would have run $2,000 or more.
For an organization running on less than six figures, none of that was realistic. We weren’t going to spend 2% of our entire budget on a salary study.
What I ended up doing was downloading raw 990 data from ProPublica and the IRS, dusting off some Python I barely remembered from college, and trying to query it myself.
It took me three days to build a 10-organization peer group, work that a well-resourced organization would simply hand to a consultant and have back in a week.
None of that work was reusable, either. The next time I needed a compensation set for a different organization, budget range, or geography, I’d have to start from scratch.
Because I had the stubbornness (and the free time) to muddle through it, our board ended up with defensible data.
But many small nonprofit boards don’t have someone willing to spend three days wrestling with IRS data, and that’s where things start to go wrong.
What I Keep Seeing Go Wrong
I now run a small consulting practice focused on operational and strategic support for nonprofits, and I’m currently serving as interim COO/CFO at Designing Justice + Designing Spaces, a social enterprise focused on restorative justice.
Through that work, I’ve gotten a close look at how boards across the sector approach executive compensation, and the same patterns come up over and over.
1. They Google it and Call it Research
A board member searches “average nonprofit executive director salary,” lands on a PayScale or Glassdoor page, and brings that number to the next meeting.
The problem is that those are self-reported national averages that don’t account for budget size, geography, or sector.
The median nonprofit executive director salary in the U.S. is roughly $98,000, but that number means nothing for a $200K community organization in rural Virginia or a $5M foundation in San Francisco.
It’s like pricing your house based on the national average home price.
2. They Benchmark Against the Wrong Peers
Even boards that try to pull real 990 data often compare themselves to organizations three or five times their budget.
A $150K youth program shouldn’t be benchmarking against a $1M health services nonprofit just because they both have “executive director” in the title.
Those are very different jobs.
3. They Don’t Document Anything
The IRS asks nonprofits to describe their compensation approval process on Form 990, Part VI, Section B, Line 15.
Boards that follow a specific three-step process (independent review, comparability data, documentation) create what’s called a “rebuttable presumption of reasonableness,” which is essentially a legal safe harbor.
But many small nonprofits don’t even know this process exists.
Often, they will set the salary in a board meeting, discuss it for maybe 10 minutes, and move on.
There are no minutes reflecting the data they reviewed, no documented peer group, and no paper trail.
4. The ED is in the Room When Their Own Pay is Decided
At smaller organizations, it’s not unusual for the executive director to also sit on the board.
When that person takes part in (or worse, leads) the conversation about their own compensation without recusing themselves, the whole process loses its independence.
The IRS specifically requires that the person receiving compensation not be part of the review body.
5. They Set it Once and Never Look Again
A board might put real effort into setting compensation during the initial hire, then never revisit it beyond annual cost-of-living bumps.
Compensation should be benchmarked against current market data every year or two, not locked in based on research that’s five years old.
What the IRS Actually Expects (It’s Not That Scary)
The good news is that the IRS has spelled out what it wants to see.
Under IRC §4958 and Treasury Regulation 53.4958-6, it lays out a three-step process that, if followed, creates a “rebuttable presumption of reasonableness”.
That means your compensation is presumed to be reasonable unless the IRS can show otherwise.
The three steps:
- An independent body reviews the compensation. Board members or a compensation committee, composed of people with no conflict of interest. That rules out the person being paid.
- That body obtains and relies on appropriate comparability data. Real data from similarly situated organizations (similar budget, sector, and geography), rather than a Google search or a single national average.
- The body documents the basis for its decision. Meeting minutes that record what data was reviewed, who was involved, and what the board concluded.
None of this is complicated. But step two is where boards tend to get stuck, because “appropriate comparability data” is either expensive to buy or tedious to compile by hand.
What I’d Do Differently Today
If I were back on the Wanna Learn More board today, facing the same problem with the same budget, I wouldn’t spend three days manually querying IRS data. The landscape has genuinely changed.
First, I’d do what I tell any board to do: Get clear on what “appropriate comparability data” actually means.
You need 8-12 organizations that look like yours: Similar annual budget (within about 25% of your revenue), the same general sector or mission area, and in a comparable geographic region.
Don’t skip geography, because cost of living matters enormously. That’s your peer group, and writing down how you chose it becomes part of the documentation the IRS expects.
Second, I’d use AI tools to help with the tedious research. They’re good at tasks like searching through a large public dataset, filtering by specific criteria, and organizing the results, which is most of what compensation benchmarking involves.
You can use them to help identify comparable organizations, pull the relevant 990 data, and calculate percentile ranges.
What took me three days of manual ProPublica searches could realistically take an afternoon. Just check the figures against the actual filings before they go in front of your board.
I also built a free tool, PeerSet, that can help with this if you’d like to use it. It searches 1.9 million Form 990 filings, lets you define a peer group by sector, budget, and geography, and exports a PDF with percentile ranges.
Regardless of how you get the data, whether you use AI, pull 990s from ProPublica manually, or pay for a report, the underlying steps are the same:
Define your peer group: 8-12 comparable organizations, matched by budget, sector, and geography.
Use real 990 data: Actual compensation figures from Form 990, Part VII, Section A, rather than self-reported surveys or national averages.
Calculate a range: Find the median, 25th percentile, and 75th percentile. This gives your board a defensible range instead of a single number to argue about.
Document everything: Write down which organizations you looked at, why you chose them, what the numbers were, and where your board landed. Put it in your board minutes. This is what creates the rebuttable presumption.
Repeat annually: Build it into your board calendar. It doesn’t have to be a massive project every year, but you should be refreshing the data so your executive director’s compensation doesn’t drift too far from the market.
Why This Matters More Than You Think
Underpaid executive directors burn out and leave. Overpaid ones erode donor trust.
Both problems can trace back to the same cause: a board without good data, making its best guess in a 15-minute conversation.
The nonprofit sector asks its leaders to do extraordinarily hard work, often for compensation well below what they’d earn in the private sector.
The least we can do is make sure the process for setting that pay is thoughtful, documented, and grounded in real numbers.
You made it to the end! Please share this article!
Let’s help other nonprofit leaders succeed! Consider sharing this article with your friends and colleagues via email or social media.
About the Author
Josh Green is the founder of RightStart, where he provides fractional executive leadership to nonprofits and mission-driven organizations, and is currently interim COO/CFO at Designing Justice + Designing Spaces, a social enterprise focused on restorative justice. He also built PeerSet, a free tool that helps nonprofit boards benchmark executive compensation using IRS Form 990 data. He sits on the boards of the Wanna Learn More Network and the Roanoke Valley Children’s Choir.
Articles on Blue Avocado do not provide legal representation or legal advice and should not be used as a substitute for advice or legal counsel. Blue Avocado provides space for the nonprofit sector to express new ideas. The opinions and views expressed in this article are solely those of the authors. They do not purport to reflect or imply the opinions or views of Blue Avocado, its publisher, or affiliated organizations. Blue Avocado, its publisher, and affiliated organizations are not liable for website visitors’ use of the content on Blue Avocado nor for visitors’ decisions about using the Blue Avocado website.

