Merging Nonprofit Voices into a Political Force
Robert Egger discusses how Citizens United v. FEC grants political free-speech rights to corporations and unions, but excludes nonprofits.
Article Highlights:
No economic recovery plan should be considered viable without the nonprofit sector.
For the last four years, I’ve been wondering what it would take to unite the nonprofit sector in America.
In 2007, at the start of the first Presidential election in almost 80 years in which there was no incumbent in the race, nonprofits could have used this competitive climate to develop a strategy that compelled all candidates to earn our collective votes. By pushing for a plan for America that included a defined role for our 1.4 million nonprofits, we could have repositioned the sector as a deep well of previously untapped, economic energy. We did not.
In 2008, when 29 states posted over $45 billion in deficits and legislators began to make deep budget cuts, the opportunity was again present. As funding for once sacrosanct programs — from senior healthcare to education — was slashed, nonprofits could have joined forces to ensure that vital services and critical needs were met. We remained divided.
And in 2009, when state budget deficits exploded by over 300% and lawmakers began to explore taxing nonprofit property or imposing other cash generating fees, I eagerly awaited the moment when enlightened self-interest would spur a sorely-needed, strategic dialogue among organizations in every community. It never came.
And now this: two weeks ago, the Supreme Court handed down a decision in the case of Citizens United v. FEC, which granted political free-speech rights to corporations and unions, but excluded groups granted 501(c)(3) status by the Internal Revenue Service. This means that the 14 million employees of organizations who train the unemployed, shelter homeless vets, sustain the arts, protect our environment, care for the sick, feed the poor, channel the energy and ideals of 60 million volunteers annually must sit on the sidelines and bear witness to a process that relies on our work, yet excludes our voice.
Does that make you mad? It should. Does that make you want to do something? It must.
Does it make you want to be part of real change? It can – and here’s how.
A once-in-a-generation opportunity
This year — 2010 — is the once-in-a-generation opportunity to shift the political calculus. Of the 50 states of our Union, 36 will elect governors. All 435 seats in the House of Representatives are up for re-election. One-third of the Senate seats are in play. All this is happening at a unique moment in American history: when every candidate, no matter their past political success or outside contributions must detail their plan to resurrect the America economy.
We nonprofits generate almost 10% of the GNP and pay billions in taxes. This is our opening. We must reframe our role on the national, state and city level by organizing around one simple axiom: no plan for economic recovery can be considered viable unless it incorporates the economic power and potential of the nonprofit sector.
And it all starts with you.
Make no mistake — our collective fate is in the balance, which is why we must now channel our collective power. As individual citizens, you have the power to speak with candidates who would ask for your vote.
In every city and state, nonprofits must use every means to communicate this commitment. Our entire country needs to understand how deeply our work is woven into the fabric of our national history and how imperative we are to ensuring our country’s future.
A national media campaign — led by you
To accomplish this, we must all participate in an ambitious national media campaign. Write editorials. Submit letters to the editor. Redesign your organizational materials so that every aspect of your work reflects on our combined accomplishments. Use new media outlets with audacity. If a candidate says something visionary about how they would partner with you — spread the word and urge other candidates to compete.
Many have talked about nonprofit mergers this year. Well, now is the time for us to merge our voices. If you do not belong to a state association, then join. If you belong to a state association, ask its leadership to stop speaking about you, and tell them to start speaking for you. Every association you belong to — whether on affordable housing or museums — must take up this call. When advocates call for your help, put everything else down and answer that call.
But you can also be part of a national movement. Beginning this month, the V3 Campaign is launching campaigns in Pennsylvania, Texas, and Michigan and is working to establish efforts in two more states.
In each case, we are partnering with local organizations to launch statewide movements so that voters will know how candidates have pledged (or not) to utilize the energy and entrepreneurial sprit of the nonprofit sector.
- If you work or volunteer in a nonprofit in one of these states, join the effort and make sure your colleagues have signed up to receive alerts from the V3 Campaign. If you are a nonprofit leader in one of these states, contact us.
- If you do not live in one of these states, the V3 Campaign website will be providing updates on political campaigns in every state. We’re launching a Twitter wire service, so that V3 will get constant updates on what candidates are saying in every community. Through this strategy, we hope to accomplish one thing: to knock down the first domino.
All it takes is for one candidate to pledge to have a Lieutenant Governor or Deputy Mayor for Philanthropy, and others will follow. All it takes is for two candidates to openly compete for our votes, and others will follow. All it will take is for the votes of nonprofits to swing a race, and others will follow.
In a year in which elections could be swayed by those who would place dividends before citizens, we must come to realize that the combined voices of the nonprofit sector could be the only force in America that can offset this imbalance and ensure open, fair and compelling campaigns.
If you believe, as I do, that America’s future is at stake, and that nonprofits have a stake in that future, then stand up, stand together and make this the year that all of America’s assets are included in the fight.
See also:
You might also like:
- Litigating a Path to Progress: Nonprofit Advocacy through the Courts
- Citizens United Unfair to One Million Corporations
- Nonprofit Staff Don’t Vote in Elections? False!
- Three Easy Ways for Foundations to Support Democracy
- Census: Battleground for Money and Justice
You made it to the end! Please share this article!
Let’s help other nonprofit leaders succeed! Consider sharing this article with your friends and colleagues via email or social media.
About the Author
Robert Egger originated the community kitchen/social enterprise model, now replicated globally. He made payroll for 30 years, while remaining 100% open-source to any and all seeking information about job training, empowerment, social enterprise, and nonprofit political activism. A noted author and speaker, he is now 100% dedicated to supporting young leaders. He can be reached at regger@fuckingshitup.net
Articles on Blue Avocado do not provide legal representation or legal advice and should not be used as a substitute for advice or legal counsel. Blue Avocado provides space for the nonprofit sector to express new ideas. The opinions and views expressed in this article are solely those of the authors. They do not purport to reflect or imply the opinions or views of Blue Avocado, its publisher, or affiliated organizations. Blue Avocado, its publisher, and affiliated organizations are not liable for website visitors’ use of the content on Blue Avocado nor for visitors’ decisions about using the Blue Avocado website.
Thanks for the call to get involved. Even though your cry for action is strategically targeted at non-profits (which we work to support – www.AHFblog.com), every citizen needs to be more proactive in knowing who is running for public office and where they stand on issues. We can’t make something better by just standing idile. Get involved!
Why not unite the nonprofit sector to bring our case to the Supreme Court to prove that because we share our roots with the corporations, all restrictions on lobbying and campaign contributions for nonprofits must be removed? Now that would be a timely rallying cry that would result in a significant shift for our level of influence! Just look back at the knee-jerk reactions that led to these restrictions and it seems quite plausible.
Sue Knaup
Executive Director
www.onestreet.org
The trade-off is nonprofit donations are tax free to the nonprofit and give a deduction to the donor. Perhaps you would allow the same status to corporations that they not pay tax on their income and offer a tax break to the purchaser of the corporation’s product of service.
Jay McCall
President
HOME USA
If ever I saw a threat to democracy, this is it. The decision by the Supreme Court is the final step in the complete takeover of the government by business and corporate interests and the final death warrant for the true participation in government by individuals.
If we, as organizations dedicated to helping and benefiting others do not band together to protect those who need us most — in this case by supporting issues and policies that benefit us — then we have failed not only ourselves but the millions of people who depend on us for help.
Philip Greene,
Volunteer and Community Outreach Coordinator, Media Relations
Americorps member
Dayton Christian Center
Dayton, OH
If ever I saw a threat to democracy, this is it. The decision by the Supreme Court is the final step in the complete takeover of the government by business and corporate interests and the final death warrant for the true participation in government by individuals.
If we, as organizations dedicated to helping and benefiting others do not band together to protect those who need us most — in this case by supporting issues and policies that benefit us — then we have failed not only ourselves but the millions of people who depend on us for help.
Philip Greene,
Volunteer and Community Outreach Coordinator, Media Relations
Americorps member
Dayton Christian Center
Dayton, OH
Go to Wikipedia and search on Santa Clara County decision. That’s the 1886 Supreme Court case that started corporations on the road to personhood. PLEASE NOTE that there is no “holding” to that effect! As noted there, the note about personhood was written by the clerk, in what’s called “obiter dicta.” That means that the Supreme Court has NOT held, as a matter of constitutional law, that corporations are people! And that means that the Congress COULD pass laws invalidating corporate personhood!
Now, as Senator Dick Durban, (D, IL) has said, “The banks own this place!” So we’re not about to get those laws easily. AND, perhaps more important, we don’t want Scalia, Roberts, et al to have the opportunity to MAKE it a holding! Therefore, organizing should be accompanied by (a) the understanding above, and (b) a plan to take an appropriate case to a more liberal Supreme Court, whenever one should appear. I’m a member of the DC Bar, and have been since 1973, I blog on government reform at www.government-reform.info. Happy to respond there. Bob Knisely
Sue,
I appreciate your comment. Will you be in DC in March? Robert, will you? The National Bicycle Summit is the 9-11 and I would relish the opportunity to talk V3 with you both.
Kathryn Moore
Miami Bicycle Coalition
Late to the party, but here’s my $.02. Other than pleading for access to the process, how can nonprofits present a "unified" voice? Nonprofits represent many different and competing views on political, religious, social, and economic issues. For example, not every nonprofit agrees that, because "funding for once sacrosanct programs — from senior healthcare to education — was slashed, nonprofits could have joined forces to ensure that vital services and critical needs were met." We remained divided because we represent a variety of views on the growth of the welfare state.
Over the past thirty years the "unite" theme has been used to essentially make many professional associations into campaign arms of the Democratic Party. I’m a librarian, and the American Library Association has "united" to freeze out any views other than the DNC’s. Take a look at ALA’s annual conferences and the lists of invited speakers, if you doubt my assessment.
Robert Egger’s call to egt involved in the political process as a single bloc takes us in the same direction.